Tastings: Navigating sea of chicken broth
Prepared chicken broth is that go-to kitchen staple when you don’t have the time (or the chicken) needed to simmer up your own. It gives soups, stews and sauces a flavor boost, and can sub for milk when making mashed potatoes.
“Broth occupies an intermediate position between stock and soup,” according to the “Oxford Companion to Food,” which notes that broth can be eaten as is, whereas a stock would normally be consumed only as an ingredient in something more complex.
But what’s in the array of cartons on supermarket shelves? And do they all taste alike? Well, the broths and stocks from our survey range in color from lemon-yellow to auburn. The taste? It varied, influenced by the ingredients in addition to the obvious broths used in their creation. Which is why we zeroed in on a few interesting ingredients we found on the labels, that is the “Who knew,” included below. Our rating is based on a scale of 1 to 9, with 5 being average.
Swanson 100 Percent Natural Chicken Broth (5.6 points; $3.45 for 32 ounces; 11 cents per ounce): “Aroma of chicken and butter, salt and spice aftertaste.” “Not much chicken flavor, bland but would be a decent base.” “Light poached chicken flavor; would buy.” “Fragrant, almost floral, herbal; pleasant light meaty flavor.” Who knew: Sugar, dehydrated onions, yeast extract, chicken fat, carrots, celery, onions
Progresso 100 Percent Natural Chicken Broth (5.6 points; $3.29 for 32 ounces; 10 cents per ounce): “Tastes of carrots and celery more than chicken, good flavor though.” “Herbs and salt and no sense of chicken.” “Good flavor. Nice chicken, not too salty.” “Sharp almost citrus hints; I like it.” Who knew: Sugar, natural flavor, carrot, onion, celery, green bell pepper
Kitchen Basics Chicken Stock (4.6 points; $3.69 for 32 ounces; 12 cents per ounce): “Herbal, hint of chicken liver, sweet herbal taste.” “Peppery, poached chicken. Carrots, touch of sweetness.” “Harsh, acid.” “Smoky overtones, chicken light.” Who knew: Honey, vegetable stocks (carrot, onion, mushroom, celery), bay (sic), thyme, pepper
O Organics Chicken Broth (4.2 points; $3.29 for 32 ounces; 10 cents per ounce): “Fair meaty aroma, onion flavors, no chicken.” “Roast chicken, strong onion-celery flavor, overwhelming.” “Herbal smell, some chicken.” “Odd flavor; can’t figure out what it is.” Who knew: Organic vegetable stock (organic carrot, organic onion, organic celery, sea salt, mushroom extract), organic evaporated cane juice, yeast extract, organic spice
Also tasted
Whole Foods 365 Organic Chicken Broth (4 points; $1.99 for 32 ounces; 6 cents per ounce): “Reminds me of Lipton’s.” “Thin no richness to flavor.” “Tastes of celery and onions.” Who knew: Organic chicken fat, organic evaporated cane juice, organic onion powder, organic garlic powder, organic cornstarch, organic tumeric (sic), organic spices, organic carrot powder
Pacific Natural Foods Organic Free Range Chicken Broth (4 points; $3.39 for 32 ounces; 11 cents per ounce): “Roasted chicken; strange floral sweet flavor.” “Burnt taste, unpleasant.” “Not overly salty, not much chicken flavor.” Who knew: Evaporated cane juice, organic onion powder, turmeric, organic flavor
Swanson Chicken Stock (2.8 points; $3.69 for 26 ounces; 14 cents per ounce): “Taste of packaged spice mix.” “Taste of vegetables overpowering.” “No chicken flavor.” “Less salty.” Who knew: Carrots, cabbage, onions, celery, celery leaves, salt, parsley
The results: A first-place tie between Swanson and Progresso.